Mycobacterium abscessus has emerged as a major scientific concern following reviews that it’s readily transmissible in health-care settings between sufferers with cystic fibrosis. We linked routinely collected whole-genome sequencing and health-care utilization knowledge with the intention of investigating the extent to which such transmission explains acquisition in sufferers with and with out cystic fibrosis in England.
On this retrospective observational study, we analysed consecutive M abscessus whole-genome sequencing knowledge from England (starting of February, 2015, to Nov 14, 2019) to determine genomically comparable isolates. Linkage to a nationwide health-care utilization database was used to analyze potential contacts between sufferers. Multivariable regression evaluation was performed to analyze elements related to acquisition of a genomically clustered pressure (genomic distance <25 single nucleotide polymorphisms [SNPs]).
2297 isolates from 906 sufferers underwent whole-genome sequencing as half of the routine Public Well being England diagnostic service. Of 14 genomic clusters containing isolates from ten or extra sufferers, all however one contained sufferers with cystic fibrosis and sufferers with out cystic fibrosis. Sufferers with cystic fibrosis have been equally prone to have clustered isolates (258 [60%] of 431 sufferers) as these with out cystic fibrosis (322 [63%] of 513 sufferers; p=0·38). Excessive-density phylogenetic clusters have been randomly distributed over a large geographical space. Most isolates with a closest genetic neighbour in keeping with potential transmission had no identifiable related epidemiological contacts. Having a clustered isolate was independently related to rising age (adjusted odds ratio 1·14 per 10 years, 95% CI 1·04–1·26), however not time spent as an hospital inpatient or outpatient. We recognized two sibling pairs with cystic fibrosis with genetically extremely divergent isolates and one pair with carefully associated isolates, and 25 uninfected presumed family contacts with cystic fibrosis.
Beforehand recognized broadly disseminated dominant clones of M abscessus aren’t restricted to sufferers with cystic fibrosis and happen in different persistent respiratory illnesses. Though our evaluation confirmed a small quantity of circumstances the place person-to-person transmission couldn’t be excluded, it didn’t help this being a serious mechanism for M abscessus dissemination at a nationwide degree in England. Total, these knowledge ought to reassure sufferers and clinicians that the danger of acquisition from different sufferers in health-care settings is comparatively low and inspire future analysis efforts to deal with figuring out routes of acquisition exterior of the cystic fibrosis health-care-associated area of interest.
The Nationwide Institute for Well being Analysis, Well being Knowledge Analysis UK, The Wellcome Belief, The Medical Analysis Council, and Public Well being England.
A big international study confirmed a number of internationally distributed dominant clades which accounted for many infections in sufferers with cystic fibrosis.
The authors hypothesised that widespread latest transmission, almost certainly oblique person-to-person transmission by way of environmental contamination (eg, by way of fomites or aerosols) in health-care settings and different shared venues was the almost certainly clarification. Based mostly on these research, worldwide pointers counsel that person-to-person transmission is likely to be an vital mechanism for M abscessus acquisition in sufferers with cystic fibrosis.
Nevertheless, smaller reviews haven’t substantiated this speculation.
No research have investigated the genomic epidemiology of M abscessus from sufferers with out cystic fibrosis.
Proof earlier than this study
We searched PubMed for research revealed from database inception to Dec 1, 2020, with no language restrictions, utilizing the phrases “Mycobacterium abscessus”, “transmission”, and “complete genome sequencing”. All research revealed so far have focussed on the molecular epidemiology of M abscessus in sufferers with cystic fibrosis. The biggest study so far recognized a number of internationally distributed dominant clones that have been chargeable for most infections in sufferers with cystic fibrosis. A number of research have discovered proof of extremely genomically associated strains amongst sufferers attending the identical cystic fibrosis centre, elevating concern about cross-infection. Nevertheless, three smaller research have recognized genomic clusters of isolates from cystic fibrosis sufferers who don’t have any epidemiological connections and concluded there was no proof of cross-transmission. Though some uncertainty exists in the literature, the predominating interpretation of the accessible knowledge is that there’s a substantial danger of cross-transmission, one thing mirrored in worldwide pointers.
Added worth of this study
The dataset in this study (in contrast to most earlier research) is unselected and sequential, together with isolates from all sufferers (irrespective of underlying prognosis) over a 5-year interval. By linking the biggest genomic dataset assembled so far with a nationwide health-care utilization database, we’ve unprecedented means to resolve potential transmission occasions. We present that M abscessus isolates from sufferers with cystic fibrosis are sometimes extremely genomically much like these with different, or no, persistent respiratory illness. These clusters are broadly geographically distributed and, in preserving with this commentary, we present that almost all sufferers with comparable isolates don’t have any identifiable epidemiological hyperlinks. We discovered a low danger of family transmission, additional implying that the danger of transmission related to short-term nosocomial publicity is prone to be low, a discovering supported by our regression evaluation.
Implications of all of the accessible proof
Earlier research, which solely analysed isolates from sufferers with cystic fibrosis, instructed genomic clusters have been propagated by (in all probability oblique) transmission amongst sufferers with cystic fibrosis in health-care services. Our study challenges this interpretation by displaying that genomic clusters of M abscessus are broadly geographically dispersed and shared throughout all affected person teams. Brief-term nosocomial publicity with regular an infection management procedures is prone to carry a low danger of person-to-person transmission. Future efforts to guard sufferers from an infection ought to deal with figuring out potential regionally or nationally distributed vectors.
A transparent understanding of cross-infection danger is essential to guard sufferers with cystic fibrosis in health-care services. Though nosocomial transmission must be minimised, interventions may additionally trigger monetary and operational challenges and psychological hurt for sufferers. Over the previous 6 years, Public Well being England (PHE) has applied whole-genome sequencing (WGS) to interchange present reference laboratory strategies for all mycobacteria, producing a near-complete dataset of all sequenced M abscessus scientific isolates in England from sufferers with and with out cystic fibrosis. These knowledge have been linked to routinely collected health-care utilization datasets, presenting an alternative to analyze person-to-person transmission of M abscessus on a nationwide scale throughout all affected person teams.
Study design and pattern assortment
On this observational study, we did a retrospective evaluation of routinely collected M abscessus WGS knowledge in England. All mycobacterial isolates are despatched to 1 of two PHE reference laboratories in London and Birmingham for WGS. Routine sequencing started in Birmingham for the Midlands at first of February, 2015, and for the north of England October, 2016; it started in London for the south of England in January, 2018. All isolates from these time factors till Nov 14, 2019, are included, in addition to all accessible isolates sequenced earlier than the routine service started (n=10). Historic information of unsequenced isolates (affected person particulars and assortment date) have been accessible from November, 1997, from Birmingham and from November, 2001, from London.
This study was performed as a public well being investigation with inner approval from PHE and due to this fact ethics committee approval was not required.
Sequencing and bioinformatics
Reads have been mapped to a reference genome (Nationwide Middle for Biotechnology Info reference sequence NC_010397·1) utilizing the PHE bioinformatics pipeline v1.0.2 and sequences have been in contrast utilizing recombination-adjusted (utilizing ClonalFrameML v1.11),
most probability phylogenies (IQTree v1.6.12);
single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) distances; and time-scaled phylogenies and molecular clock estimation (BEAST v1.10.4; appendix p 2).
Inside-patient range was estimated utilizing all sequenced isolates for sufferers for whom a couple of of these have been accessible. We additionally did a sensitivity evaluation to find out the impact of selection of reference (appendix p 3). Clusters of isolates doubtlessly in keeping with latest transmission have been recognized utilizing the beforehand outlined genomic threshold of fewer than 25 SNPs.
assuming that sufferers might turn out to be contaminated with M abscessus as much as 1 12 months earlier than first isolation and remained doubtlessly infectious from this level onwards. We used the date of first isolation of M abscessus (whether or not sequenced or not) for the epidemiological evaluation and regarded the primary isolate per cluster per affected person (ie, if a affected person had isolates in a number of clusters the primary from every was included).
To determine potential family contacts we searched the health-care utilization database (HES) to determine sufferers with cystic fibrosis who lived on the similar postcode as a cystic fibrosis affected person in our dataset in the 12 months in which M abscessus was first remoted from them. Though the imply quantity of households inside a postcode is roughly 15, the inhabitants prevalence of cystic fibrosis is such that almost all pairs of people sharing the identical full postcode and each with cystic fibrosis could be anticipated to be in the identical family. The place these pairs have been additionally each current in our laboratory information (therefore had each had M abscessus remoted) and shared a surname, we outlined these as siblings. One potential sibling pair was recognized in which people shared a surname however weren’t family contacts in the 12 months of acquisition (however had been beforehand).
to find out whether or not noticed values have been suitable with the null speculation of no regional clustering of isolates (appendix p 3). We moreover calculated the Pearson correlation between distance to nearest genomic neighbour (in SNPs) and geographical distance (measured utilizing the Harversine distance) between affected person’s postcodes. We generated a phylogenetic tree together with all isolates from this and three earlier research.
For every issue included in the fashions, the percentages ratio (OR; or adjusted OR [aOR] the place related) and 95% CIs have been calculated. Solely the primary isolate per affected person was used. Because it was unclear what related exposures is likely to be, we thought-about this evaluation to be exploratory and initially included all demographic, scientific, and socioeconomic elements accessible. To make sure that solely variables making a major contribution have been included, the ultimate mannequin was fitted by backwards elimination utilizing the Akaike Info Standards, permitting for potential interactions and non-linearity (appendix p 4). We moreover did a secondary regression evaluation utilizing the identical methodology to analyze elements related to buying a clustered isolate in sufferers with cystic fibrosis. For all statistical exams we thought-about p
Function of the funding supply
The funder of the study had no function in study design, knowledge assortment, knowledge evaluation, knowledge interpretation, or writing of the report.
We estimated a molecular clock of 1·1 SNPs per genome per 12 months (95% highest posterior density interval 0·9–1·4), in keeping with the imply time to most up-to-date frequent ancestor for 2 clustered strains being roughly 10·9 years. We discovered that this threshold represented greater than 95% of within-patient range (median time between first and final sequenced isolates 246 days [IQR 77–570]) in the identical subspecies, which is in keeping with earlier research (appendix p 9).
92 (80%) of 115 clusters contained at the least one affected person with cystic fibrosis, 68 of which crossed illness strata (ie, contained at the least one cystic fibrosis affected person and one affected person with a special or no respiratory prognosis). We reasoned that if cystic fibrosis communities or health-care services are the first facilitators of clonal outbreaks, then the quantity of clusters containing completely cystic fibrosis sufferers should be better than could be anticipated by probability. This was not the case (noticed proportion of completely cystic fibrosis clusters 0·21, permuted 95% CI 0·00–0·22). For sufferers with cystic fibrosis, the median genomic distance to the closest affected person with cystic fibrosis was 24 SNPs (IQR 9–51) whereas the median genomic distance to the closest affected person with out cystic fibrosis was 31 SNPs (8–67, p=0·093).
we thought-about the chance that beforehand described clusters may need regularly died out after this era and due to this fact be unrelated to these described right here. Bayesian courting evaluation confirmed that each one bigger clusters in all probability emerged earlier than this era (figure 3). We recognized 107 sufferers in these clusters with earlier (unsequenced) isolates pre-dating the implementation of enhanced an infection management procedures and for the needs of our epidemiological evaluation assumed these would largely fall in the identical cluster as later sequenced isolates. As we analysed epidemiological knowledge from the date of first acquisition (not sequencing date), if substantial person-to-person transmission was occurring earlier than the introduction of the brand new pointers we’d have anticipated to have noticed it.
DeskMultivariable predictors of buying a clustered Mycobacterium abscessus isolate
Knowledge are n (%), median (IQR), or OR (95% CI, p worth). 45 sufferers had a number of incomplete datapoint and have been excluded from the mannequin. Univariate estimates (ORs) are proven for all variables, multivariable estimates (aOR) are solely proven for variables included in the ultimate mannequin. Inpatient days, outpatient attendances, and respiratory procedures confer with the quantity of these in the 12 months earlier than M abscessus was first remoted from the affected person. OR=odds ratio. aOR=adjusted OR.
we noticed that the genomes of isolates obtained from earlier international research have been distributed all through the phylogeny of English isolates obtained in this study (appendix p 14).
We analysed consecutive, unselected genomic knowledge linked to health-care information to analyze the extent of person-to-person transmission of M abscessus in England. Genomic clusters of M abscessus aren’t disease-specific; solely a minority are unique to cystic fibrosis. As has beforehand been proven to be the case for sufferers with cystic fibrosis, most sufferers with out cystic fibrosis in England are colonised with a clustered isolate. This case is opposite to what could be anticipated if, as at present postulated, outbreak strains are primarily propagated in nosocomial cystic fibrosis environments. It was notably notable that a number of sufferers with non-respiratory isolates (eg, pores and skin abscesses, bone aspirates, or peritoneal dialysis fluid) had genomically near-identical isolates to respiratory sufferers. We noticed no geographical construction to the phylogeny and in preserving with this, by linking genomic knowledge to an in depth nationwide epidemiological database, confirmed that almost all sufferers in clusters don’t have any identifiable epidemiological hyperlinks. Earlier research sequenced chosen saved isolates completely from teams of sufferers with cystic fibrosis and due to this fact don’t signify the complete panorama of M abscessus epidemiology. Our findings have vital implications for future efforts to guard sufferers.
A standard supply of scientific concern happens the place M abscessus is remoted from a number of sufferers attending the identical clinic on the identical day. In most of such circumstances in this study, the genomes sequenced have been unrelated, successfully excluding person-to-person transmission. Though we recognized a small quantity of circumstances (roughly 5% of sufferers) in which the genomic relatedness of isolates and potential epidemiological connections could possibly be suitable with person-to-person transmission, this quantity represents an higher sure estimate of the true extent of transmission given the built-in service design of regional cystic fibrosis networks and the excessive quantity of epidemiological contacts due to this fact anticipated by probability. It’s exhausting to elucidate how sufferers who reside in geographically separate areas, don’t entry the identical health-care services, and are unlikely to share social connections might transmit, even not directly, between one another. Except there’s a important reservoir of wholesome and asymptomatic carriers in the overall inhabitants, it’s unlikely that widespread person-to-person transmission explains our observations. We hypothesise that nationwide dissemination by way of a broadly distributed, presumably water-associated publicity, could possibly be suitable with our knowledge given what is thought concerning the environmental ecology of non-tuberculous mycobacteria and the large geographical distribution of clusters we observe. A outstanding instance of this has been proven for M chimaera,
though our knowledge would counsel that the related publicity for M abscessus is extra generally encountered in the neighborhood.
Our regression evaluation recognized age as being considerably related to the danger of buying a clustered pressure however there was no affiliation with elevated hospital contact. Older and multi-comorbid sufferers is likely to be repeatedly uncovered to clustered strains by way of some unknown environmental vector whereas non-clustered strains are sporadically discovered in a extremely various environmental pool that these sufferers are much less uncovered to. The discovering that sufferers with cystic fibrosis seem like marginally protected against acquisition of a clustered isolate with rising time spent as an inpatient is prone to be spurious however is likely to be defined by diminished publicity if these strains are primarily neighborhood acquired. Though we recognized one pair of siblings in whom family transmission may need occurred, the rarity of transmission amongst people with possible family publicity means that transmission from short-term nosocomial publicity could be even rarer, which is in keeping with our observations on the nationwide degree. However some extremely infectious sufferers might presumably transmit to different sufferers, particularly in the case of a breakdown in an infection management procedures.
Our findings might due to this fact be interpreted as representing proof of the effectiveness of these measures; nonetheless, we expect this clarification is unlikely. Stringent an infection management measures and the precept of segregating sufferers with cystic fibrosis from one another have been in place lengthy earlier than the introduction of these enhanced procedures.
Most new clusters are nonetheless attributable to clustered isolates. Bayesian courting evaluation of bigger clusters revealed that these arose earlier than the introduction of enhanced an infection management procedures, suggesting that these had minimal efficacy to disrupt their prorogation. Moreover, if transmission was predominantly related to health-care settings earlier than the introduction of these measures and subsequent interventions efficient, we’d anticipate the incidence of circumstances in sufferers with cystic fibrosis to alter considerably; this has not been noticed.
We’d additionally anticipate a divergence in the epidemiology of M abscessus between sufferers with and with out cystic fibrosis (notably these with non-cystic fibrosis bronchiectasis). No such distinction was noticed.
Research that solely sequence isolates throughout suspected outbreaks or isolates chosen for storage danger bias. The comparatively unselected nature of our affected person inhabitants is a key power of this study. Limitations embody potential ascertainment bias resulting in over-representation of sufferers with cystic fibrosis because of heightened consciousness of M abscessus an infection in this neighborhood in latest years, the non-availability of sequences for pre-2015 isolates, and our assumption that sufferers stay colonised with the identical pressure. The use of an arbitrary SNP threshold is an extra limitation but in addition permits direct comparability with earlier research and displays present public well being follow.
In abstract, the commentary in this and different research of broadly disseminated genetically near-identical clones is putting, however crucially these aren’t restricted to sufferers with cystic fibrosis. It’s troublesome to elucidate how cross-transmission might have led to the widespread geographical dispersion of clonal lineages we’ve noticed amongst sufferers, the overwhelming majority of whom don’t have any epidemiological hyperlinks. Though it’s potential that these clones are asymptomatically carried by a a lot wider inhabitants than beforehand thought, it appears extra possible that an as but unidentified, broadly distributed, environmental vector would possibly underlie M abscessus clusters in sufferers with persistent respiratory illness (not simply cystic fibrosis). Our knowledge clearly present that future research and an infection management approaches should think about a wider focus than completely a cystic fibrosis health-care-associated area of interest. The identification in this study and others of potential cross-transmission occasions warrants ongoing genomic surveillance and is one of many elements justifying excessive ranges of an infection management inside services that deal with sufferers with cystic fibrosis. These knowledge ought to, nonetheless, additionally present reassurance to clinicians and sufferers and their households that the danger of acquisition of M abscessus from different sufferers in health-care settings is low. These knowledge additionally underline the worth of unselected sampling frames when making inferences on the premise of molecular epidemiology.
TMW, DWE, TEAP, SL, and DWC designed the study. SL, TEAP, TMW, SC, WF, ASW, and DWE designed the evaluation; SL did the evaluation. SL wrote the primary draft of the manuscript. BM-P, NP, RM, EA, EGS, ER, DWC, and SH have been concerned in curation of knowledge, entry to assets, funding acquisition, and data governance. DWE, TEAP, and DWC supervised the venture. NW and NH have been concerned in knowledge assortment. SL, TMW, DWE, TEAP, DWC, ASW, NH, SC, and WF contributed to knowledge interpretation. SL, TMW, and DWE verified the information. All authors commented on a draft of the manuscript and permitted the ultimate model. All authors had full entry to all the information in the study and had ultimate duty for the choice to submit for publication.
Declaration of pursuits
DWE declares grants from Robertson Basis and lecture charges from Gilead, exterior the submitted work. TMW is a Wellcome Belief Medical Profession Improvement Fellow ( 214560/Z/18/Z ). All different authors declare no competing pursuits.
The analysis was supported by the Nationwide Institute for Well being Analysis (NIHR) Well being Safety Analysis Unit in Healthcare Related Infections and Antimicrobial Resistance (HPRU 2012–10041) on the College of Oxford in partnership with Public Well being England (PHE) and by Oxford NIHR Biomedical Analysis Centre. TEAP, ASW, and DWC are NIHR senior investigators. Computation used the Oxford Biomedical Analysis Computing (BMRC) facility, a joint improvement between the Wellcome Centre for Human Genetics and the Massive Knowledge Institute supported by Well being Knowledge Analysis UK and the NIHR Oxford Biomedical Analysis Centre. The report presents impartial analysis funded by NIHR. The views expressed in this publication are these of the authors and never essentially these of the NHS, NIHR, the Division of Well being or PHE . SL is supported by a Medical Analysis Council Medical Analysis Coaching Fellowship.
Opportunistic pathogens enriched in showerhead biofilms.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2009; 106: 16393-16399
Nontuberculous mycobacteria from family plumbing of sufferers with nontuberculous mycobacteria illness.
Emerg Infect Dis. 2011; 17: 419-424
Emergence and unfold of a human-transmissible multidrug-resistant nontuberculous mycobacterium.
Science. 2016; 354: 751-757
Entire-genome sequencing to determine transmission of Mycobacterium abscessus between sufferers with cystic fibrosis: a retrospective cohort study.
Lancet. 2013; 381: 1551-1560
Investigating transmission of Mycobacterium abscessus amongst youngsters in an Australian cystic fibrosis centre.
J Cyst Fibros. 2020; 19: 219-224
British Thoracic Society pointers for the administration of non-tuberculous mycobacterial pulmonary illness (NTM-PD).
Thorax. 2017; 72: ii1-i64
US Cystic Fibrosis Basis and European Cystic Fibrosis Society consensus suggestions for the administration of non-tuberculous mycobacteria in people with cystic fibrosis.
Thorax. 2016; 71: i1-22
Cross-transmission shouldn’t be the supply of new Mycobacterium abscessus infections in a multicenter cohort of cystic fibrosis sufferers.
Clin Infect Dis. 2020; 70: 1855-1864
Mycobacterium abscessus in sufferers with cystic fibrosis: low impression of inter-human transmission in Italy.
Eur Respir J. 2017; 501602525
Entire-genome sequencing and epidemiological evaluation don’t present proof for cross-transmission of Mycobacterium abscessus in a cohort of pediatric cystic fibrosis sufferers.
Clin Infect Dis. 2015; 60: 1007-1016
Analysis of whole-genome sequencing for mycobacterial species identification and drug susceptibility testing in a scientific setting: a large-scale potential evaluation of efficiency towards line probe assays and phenotyping.
J Clin Microbiol. 2018; 56 (): e01480
ClonalFrameML: environment friendly inference of recombination in complete bacterial genomes.
PLoS Comput Biol. 2015; 11e1004041
IQ-TREE: a quick and efficient stochastic algorithm for estimating maximum-likelihood phylogenies.
Mol Biol Evol. 2015; 32: 268-274
BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary evaluation by sampling timber.
BMC Evol Biol. 2007; 7: 214
Two distinct patterns of Clostridium difficile range throughout Europe indicating contrasting routes of unfold.
Clin Infect Dis. 2018; 67: 1035-1044
Genomic epidemiology of a nationwide outbreak of post-surgical Mycobacterium abscessus wound infections in Brazil.
Microb Genom. 2017; 3e000111
Mycobacterium abscessus. Suggestions for an infection prevention and management November 2017. Report of the Cystic Fibrosis Belief Mycobacterium abscessus An infection Management Working Group.
Cystic Fibrosis Belief,
World outbreak of extreme Mycobacterium chimaera illness after cardiac surgical procedure: a molecular epidemiological study.
Lancet Infect Dis. 2017; 17: 1033-1041
Requirements for the scientific care of youngsters and adults with cystic fibrosis in the UK.
Cystic Fibrosis Belief,
Publication Historical past
© 2021 The Writer(s). Printed by Elsevier Ltd.